Monday, May 20, 2013

Walk Two Moons (by Sharon Creech)

Reviewed by Tara Davis

Background and Summary

            Author Sharon Creech was born July 29, 1945 and grew up in South Euclid, Ohio. Before becoming an author, Creech was an English teacher and an editorial assistant. She lived eighteen years in England then came back to the United States and wrote Walk Two Moons, Creech’s first book published in America. Several of Creech’s novels have won the Carnegie Medal, the British Carnegie, and the American Newbery Medal. Creech wrote Walk Two Moons in 1994 and won the Newbery Medal in 1995. Creech originally wrote Walk Two Moons as a sequel to Absolutely No Chaos but then changed the idea of the novel after she began writing. Walk Two Moons parallels Creech’s childhood: growing up in Euclid, Ohio, visiting her cousins in Lewis County, Kentucky, and her love of nature. Creech has also written fifteen other Young Adult novels, including Love That Dog, Chasing Redbird, and The Wanderer.

Sharon Creech’s first novel written in America, Walk Two Moons, is about a Native American thirteen-year-old girl who is taking a road trip with her grandparents to her mother’s final resting place in Lewiston, Idaho. Salamanca Tree Hiddle, who goes by the nickname Sal, lost her mother in a car accident a year before the story begins, although the reader is not aware of Sal’s mother’s death until the story ends. Up until a year before, Salamanca lives with her mom and dad in Bybanks, Kentucky, on a beautiful farm. But her mother is unable to shake off a deep sense of inadequacy next to her selfless husband, so she decides to take a road trip to Lewiston, to figure out who she really is. But on the way to Lewiston, the bus she is traveling in spins off the road and catches on fire. The crash kills every passenger except Margaret Cadaver, a thirty-year-old nurse who lives in Euclid, Ohio. After the terrible accident, Sal’s father decides to move from Bybanks to Euclid, to befriend Margaret and seek consolation from his loss.

 While Sal and her grandparents drive across the United States, Gram and Gramps decide to travel in Sal’s mother’s tracks by visiting the tourist attractions that were on the postcards that she sent to Sal while on her trip. Along the way, Sal tells her grandparents about her friend Phoebe Winterbottom, a snobby rich girl with a wild imagination, whose mother has also ran away. Through the stories Sal tells her grandparents about Phoebe, the reader learns the connection between the Winterbottom and the Hiddle family; Phoebe’s mother, like Sal’s mother, also struggles with the feeling of inadequacy and not being appreciated for everything she does for her family. Mrs. Winterbottom decides to leave home without explanation in order to mend her past and figure out who she really is. While Sal is telling her grandparents about Phoebe’s family, Sal realizes how important her own family is and that she needs to value every moment she has with her dad, gram, and grandpa. Most importantly, Sal learns to not judge others before giving them a chance, to forgive her mother for leaving and her father for moving to Euclid. Sal also learns how to move forward after her mother’s death.   

Interest                                                                                                                                  

            This story would is appropriate for readers in the middle adolescence stage (5th-6th grade), especially to girls. Because this story involves high emotions and drama of the female main character, it is not a book that boys would enjoy; however boys might enjoy certain characters in the story, such as Gram and Gramps due to their eccentric behavior, but males would not connect to the story as an entirety. While this story would not particularly appeal to boys, the leading female characters, the drama, the road trip across the west, and learning more about oneself and those around her, are all aspects that middle adolescent females would be able to connect with.

Developing Mature Readers

            This book deals with several tasks young people face as they mature. Independence from Parents: Salamanca’s mother dies a year before the story starts, although the reader does not learn this fact until the end of the story. Sal struggles with her mother’s sudden departure and goes through a rebellious stage; she will not listen to her father’s explanation for moving to Euclid, Ohio, Sal will not give Margaret a chance to explain why Mr. Hiddle (Sal’s father) and she are friends. Sal’s friend Phoebe Winterbottom also struggles with independence from her parents. Phoebe’s mother has also disappeared without explanation and refuses to let her father take control of the situation. While the story unravels, the reader learns that although Sal is fighting the inevitable separation from her mother, along the trip to Lewiston, Sal is growing closer to her father and to her grandparents. Sal’s reconciliation with her father teaches readers that an individual can experience the loss of a parent, but she is still emotionally dependent on a family member’s love and acceptance.

 Relationships with the Opposite Gender: When Sal moves to Euclid, Ohio she is forced to meet new friends. One person particularly Sal befriends is Ben, a thirteen year-old-boy who is also forced to grow independent from his mother, who was admitted to a psychiatric ward. Ben and Sal’s relationship, though platonic for the majority of the story, grows increasingly romantic as the story unfolds. Through this aspect of the story a reader learns that her peers face the same trials she faces and she is not the only one experiencing the loss of a parent. The reader also learns through this aspect of the story that pursuing friendships with girls as well as with boys is acceptable.

 Sense of Accomplishment: Sal’s goal throughout the novel is to reach her mother’s final resting place in Lewiston, Idaho. Her goal is made evident to the reader throughout the novel; Sal hears the wind whisper to her: “hurry, hurry,” or “rush, rush.” When Gram and Gramps spend too long at a certain tourist spot, Sal becomes anxious, wanting to reach Lewiston in a certain number of days in order to reach the town for her mother’s birthday. As Sal and her grandparents draw closer to Lewiston, Sal no longer hears the wind whispering to her; this is an indication that Sal has finally accepted her mother’s death and that life must now move forward. Sal’s goal of reaching Lewiston for her mother’s birthday is accomplished at the end of the story. This task teaches readers that a personal goal takes time to accomplish and is a physical and emotional journey. Creech presents Sal’s accomplishment in both a negative and a positive way. Sal’s goal is presented negatively because she takes the time she has with her grandparents for granted, focusing only on reaching her mother’s resting place. At the same time, Sal’s accomplishment is presented positively because her adventure across the west helps her move forward from her mother’s death. 
 
Potential Issues
 
            One aspect of this book that is an issue is the worldview. The worldview in this story could easily come across as pantheistic. The main characters in the story, the Hiddle family, are Native American, so Sal prays to nature. A second aspect of this book that is an issue is the role of the mother; children might get the idea that running away from family issues is permissible by the actions of Mrs. Winterbottom and Mrs. Hiddle. Creech presents the role of the mother in a negative way; Mrs. Hiddle believes she is an inadequate spouse, so she decides to leave her family and Mrs. Winterbottom is not appreciated for her hard work. Both mothers in this story cannot emotionally handle their role and try to escape that role. On the other hand, Creech presents Mrs. Hiddle’s and Mrs. Winterbottom’s reaction to their feelings negatively; Mrs. Hiddle dies in a car accident and Mrs. Winterbottom is forced to untangle the web of lies she has formed. A third aspect of this novel that is an issue is Sal and Phoebe’s disobedience. After the mothers disappear, Phoebe and Sal are disobedient to their dads. The novel presents the girls’ disobedience in a negative light; both Phoebe’s and Sal’s father tries to explain the disappearance, but Phoebe and Sal refuse to listen and try to take matters into their own hands.

 Recommendations

 I recommend this novel for middle adolescents, fifth to seventh graders, and teachers. Scholastic recommends this novel for third grade through eighth grade. I believe this story could be taught in either public or Christian school; however, the teachers would definitely have to talk through the behavior of Phoebe’s and Sal’s mothers, and Phoebe and Sal’s disobedience. If taught in a Christian school, Christian school teachers have an opportunity to address the novel’s Pantheism. If I used this book in a classroom I would assign it as outside reading for individual students rather than reading the story as a class. The reason for this recommendation is that boys would not take interest in the story, and some of the girls might not want to finish reading the novel because of its slow pace.

 Resources for Teaching or Research

 Parents or teachers wanting to use this novel in their curriculum have many resources available to help students learn the content and themes of the story in a fun and creative way. First, the website Scholastic has many lesson plans, creative activities for students, writing prompt questions, and vocabulary lists for Walk Two Moons. Bright Hub Education is another website that offers teachers and parents creative activities for students to become engaged in the story, along with quizzes and a story analysis provided for the teacher or parent. Third, the website Teaching Books offers an alternative to simply reading Walk two Moons. This website, along with lesson plans, also provides an audiobook for students to listen as he or she reads.

 Strategies for Teaching

            Along with lesson plans, chapter quizzes, vocabulary quizzes, and writing prompts, educational website, Scholastic provides teachers and parents with exceptionally creative ideas. Scholastic realizes that chapter quizzes are not always the most effective way to help students remember chapter content, so author and teacher Lori Licciardo-Musso suggests chapter quiz alternatives.

One activity Licciardo-Musso suggests is for each child to create a brochure and a map. of each tourist site Sal and her grandparents visit in the novel. In Walk Two Moons Sal and her grandparents travel to various famous geographical places throughout the United States. Students can create a colorful map of America and travel brochures of each tourist site that Sal and her grandparents visited.

Another activity students can do with this novel is create a pizza. the plot of Walk Two Moons unfolds quickly and students will not want to stop each chapter (there are forty-four chapters) to do an activity or quiz, therefore Lori suggests that instead of interrupting each chapter, each student should a symbolic pizza. On one side of the pizza the student will make a collage of important themes from the book. On the other side the student will divide the pizza into six equal parts and each slice will have a chapter summary will have a chapter summary of seven chapters.

Furthermore, students can expand their vocabulary. Walk Two Moons contains a copious amount of funny words such as ‘caboodle,’ ‘diabolic,’ ‘gallantly,’ and ‘pandemonium.’ The teacher can use the new words from this book to put together a vocabulary list for the students to learn and interact with.

 Works Cited

Creech, Sharon. Walk Two Moons.  New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 1994. Print.

iVillage. “Two Activities for Teaching Themes from ‘Walk Two Moons.’” Bright Hub

 Education. 2012. Web. 17 Apr. 2013.

Scholastic. “Walk Two Moons Lesson Plan.” Scholastic. 2013. Web. 16 Apr. 2013.

Teaching Books. “Walk Two Moons.” Teaching Books. 2013. Web. 17 Apr. 2013.